Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 1,317
Lord of Whaaaaat
*
OP Offline
Lord of Whaaaaat
*
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 1,317
http://www.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/asiapcf/05/04/bin.laden.compound/index.html?hpt=T1

There aren't any of the man himself, but some pictures of the wreckage of one of these new "stealth blackhawks"...pretty sweet. Also there's some photos of a few a of the guys they killed, they're pretty graphic.

I still have a lot of reservations about this whole "story" the government is whipping up. A lot of things aren't adding up to me.

1) How was he so deep within the pakistani border?

2) Who was this compound built for and what is their relation to him?

3) Who are these other random "family" members that lived there with him and have they been questioned by any government officials? U.S. or Pakistani?

4) First they say he was "armed", then they say he was not "armed" but "resisting". Any extremist butthole would have realized what was happening after the helicopters landed and had plenty of time to grab a weapon. We could probably defer that he was unarmed and not resisting. I'm thinking they just went in guns blazing. I'm not questioning the conduct of the SEALS, I would have pulled the trigger too if indeed that is what heppened. But the gov needs to get their shit straight and tell it right. It's not like they dropped out of a tree and ninja'd his ass (in a literal sense anyway). Neighbors saw the helicopters as they landed...the notion that the other 17 people in the compound didn't, highly unlikely.

5) They dump the body 3 hours after making the kill, essentially because they don't want to "anger" muslims. Honestly I can't remember the last time we did anything that didn't. Maintaining forensic evidence is pretty important. Not saying we should mummify him or anything...but 3 hours? Really?

6) DNA Test? This would need to be done in a pretty sterile environment for good results...I didn't think it was possible within 24 hours but apparently it is. Still given the circumstances, it's hard to believe they got the match as fast as they announced it.

7) Last night Fox news reported the operation actually consisted of 79 navy seals. Those two new choppers must have some sick closet spaces. That of course, has now been reverted back to 24. This is probably due to Fox New's own idiocy though, being the worst source of news on the planet.

8) Not releasing photos...this one is pretty simple really. Don't make claims that you've ended the biggest manhunt in world history without showing evidence to back those claims. Regardless of your reasoning. If someone says they have a 600 lbs. lion as their best friend, you don't just take their word for it. Especially when that someone has been telling lies and consistently getting away with it for decades.

I'm not sure what to think right now...I know the military doesn't just fly around and crash new helicopters unless they have a good reason...but I think the administration is doing a pretty good job of providing misinformation, which means they probably have something to hide.





Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 8,917
Adept
**
Offline
Adept
**
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 8,917
Well my take on this is if the dude comes out with a new video discrediting our claims, then we know it's a lie. If we never hear from the guy again....

Of course my girl said if he was smart, he would have made a video like that anyway in advance and had his lackeys publish it after his death just to throw doubt in the minds of Americans.

I told her she should have been a terrorist. :-P

Seriously though, if the guy isn't dead, he will definitely go public because the biggest blow he could deliver to the US morale would be to make us believe our leaders are bunch of scumbag liars.




Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 2,182
Lord of Mustachio Mother Fuckers
*****
Offline
Lord of Mustachio Mother Fuckers
*****
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 2,182
Originally Posted By: Vermithrax
the biggest blow he could deliver to the US morale would be to make us believe our leaders are bunch of scumbag liars.


I think what you meant to say was that it would reinforce the widespread belief that our leaders are a bunch of scumbag liars.


"In the absence of orders, go find something and kill it." - Field Marshal Erwin Rommel
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 11,811
The Angry Mythbuster
**
Offline
The Angry Mythbuster
**
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 11,811
Originally Posted By: [LoD
Setzer]http://www.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/asiapcf/05/04/bin.laden.compound/index.html?hpt=T1

There aren't any of the man himself, but some pictures of the wreckage of one of these new "stealth blackhawks"...pretty sweet. Also there's some photos of a few a of the guys they killed, they're pretty graphic.

I still have a lot of reservations about this whole "story" the government is whipping up. A lot of things aren't adding up to me.

1) How was he so deep within the pakistani border?

2) Who was this compound built for and what is their relation to him?

3) Who are these other random "family" members that lived there with him and have they been questioned by any government officials? U.S. or Pakistani?

4) First they say he was "armed", then they say he was not "armed" but "resisting". Any extremist butthole would have realized what was happening after the helicopters landed and had plenty of time to grab a weapon. We could probably defer that he was unarmed and not resisting. I'm thinking they just went in guns blazing. I'm not questioning the conduct of the SEALS, I would have pulled the trigger too if indeed that is what heppened. But the gov needs to get their shit straight and tell it right. It's not like they dropped out of a tree and ninja'd his ass (in a literal sense anyway). Neighbors saw the helicopters as they landed...the notion that the other 17 people in the compound didn't, highly unlikely.

5) They dump the body 3 hours after making the kill, essentially because they don't want to "anger" muslims. Honestly I can't remember the last time we did anything that didn't. Maintaining forensic evidence is pretty important. Not saying we should mummify him or anything...but 3 hours? Really?

6) DNA Test? This would need to be done in a pretty sterile environment for good results...I didn't think it was possible within 24 hours but apparently it is. Still given the circumstances, it's hard to believe they got the match as fast as they announced it.

7) Last night Fox news reported the operation actually consisted of 79 navy seals. Those two new choppers must have some sick closet spaces. That of course, has now been reverted back to 24. This is probably due to Fox New's own idiocy though, being the worst source of news on the planet.

8) Not releasing photos...this one is pretty simple really. Don't make claims that you've ended the biggest manhunt in world history without showing evidence to back those claims. Regardless of your reasoning. If someone says they have a 600 lbs. lion as their best friend, you don't just take their word for it. Especially when that someone has been telling lies and consistently getting away with it for decades.

I'm not sure what to think right now...I know the military doesn't just fly around and crash new helicopters unless they have a good reason...but I think the administration is doing a pretty good job of providing misinformation, which means they probably have something to hide.






I've been keeping up with all of the information released so far. This is the jist:

1) In 2005, Bush had his CIA director remove Bin Laden as their priority for capture. Around this time, Bin Laden's courier purchased and built their villa on this land. Bin Laden's wife, who was captured in the raid, has said they have been there since 2005. She even says she has never left the second floor of the villa the entire time she has lived there. Never gone to town, never gone outside. Never left the second floor.

2) Bin Laden's Courier purchased and built the villa and the walls and the security systems.

3) His wife and all his handlers\most trusted bodyguards.

4) He was not armed. He did not use a woman as a human shield. He was shot because that is the only decision that SHOULD be made in this type of situation. The last thing any country would want is to put that guy on trial. There would be kidnappings\ransoms setup by al qaeda world wide. Saying to release him or people will die. He would be held up in court for years upon years and politically. His name wouldn't fade away into obscurity. It would be plastered all over the news until the day he put to a hanging. In which he would have died anyway. It would be an absolute political disaster.

5 & 6) Cut hair, place in bag. Insert vial in arm, pull blood, place in bag. Pretty easy to keep tests sterile. Why would you need more than a few hours to do this? Why would you hold onto a body once you've collected its DNA? They probably have plenty of photos and video of the corpse. So why keep it? This keeps the operating quick and clean.

7) Dunno, but those choppers they were flying were Top Secret and heavily modified. They could have been designed to carry any number of troops. From what I heard, because of the silencing technology it wasn't able to get liftoff after dropping off troops and so we had to blow it up so enemies couldn't get any advanced technology off the chopper.

8) If music has taught me anything it is that everyone wants to watch things die while living vicariously from a good safe distance. It doesn't make it right. People were saying Obama didn't have a real birth certificate until 2 weeks ago. So maybe if everyone keeps bugging him for it he will show the picture. Even so, ten-thousand uneducated idiots can claim it's photo shopped because the color of the blood looks fake or the shadow is off 1 degree. Releasing a photo does nothing to satisfy the massive amounts of people who will never be satisfied no matter what you give them. Lets not even go into the thousands of extremists who are willing to blow themselves up because of a cartoon showing Mohammed's face. Imagine Osama's face with a hole in it? How can any good come out of that?

I've heard a bunch of other stuff, but most of it is unverified or hearsay at this point. A few things that are hearsay right now, but might not be in a couple days.

For example, rumors are circulating that Pakistan's Intelligence absolutely knew Osama was in that compound. Neighbors are reporting to news agencies that they often saw Government agents monitoring the compound. A lot of them thought it was a foreign diplomat who lived there because of the massive security and the Pakistani Intelligence surveillance. In 2008 a diplomatic cable (leaked this year by wikileaks) was leaked that talked about the couriers high level affiliation with Osama Bin Laden and that he was of top interest for questioning. The property of the compound was in that couriers name.

Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 2,924
Lord of the Clutch
***
Offline
Lord of the Clutch
***
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 2,924
i swear this has something to do w/the "alleged" moon landing!


Alert The Clutch
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 4,433
Lord
***
Offline
Lord
***
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 4,433
LUNAR!!

No good will come from pics being released. Hop on cnn and take a look at the other dead body's and you can piece it together.

Micheal Moore is a retard, I laughed at his interview last night. Is he really spewing the execution card like its some big conspiracy. Who gives a crap one way or another. I mean for god sakes I would of pumped rounds into that fuckers ass too without hesitation. Imagine if he was sporting the patented al qaeda underwear bomb and killed some of the operators?

Bottom line. The facts will always be in question regardless of the source on this matter.

Joined: May 2002
Posts: 8,601
[
Lord of Controversy
***
Offline
Lord of Controversy
***
[
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 8,601
i also agree. theres no reason to post any pics of what happened. too many people with too much time thinking up too ridiculous of a conspiracy.


Click to reveal..
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,176
Member
***
Offline
Member
***
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 2,176
Seriously just devil's advocating (because I don't care either way on this issue)...


I would like to know where they got the initial sample from bin Laden for DNA comparison. Sure they are 100 percent certain the sample they took from the dead guy belonged to the dead guy... but what did they do... swab an envelope on which his name was the return addressee for the comparison?

I don't see how a kill shot of bin Laden would be worse than the ones they released of the others killed in the compound.

I have to be honest... I find the story about them dumping the body at sea pretty sketchy. I'm not saying the only alternative is they made the whole thing up... perhaps they have the body and just do not want to release it/info about having his body.

Also, we KILLED the guy. It's like "Hi, I blew your master's brains out... but I buried him the way he would have liked to be buried. So we are cool, yea?" How does burying him right really save us from upsetting people when we are announcing we killed him?

I feel like the logic holes are kinda obvious in this one.

Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 8,917
Adept
**
Offline
Adept
**
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 8,917
Originally Posted By: [LoD
Rainman]

He was shot because that is the only decision that SHOULD be made in this type of situation. The last thing any country would want is to put that guy on trial. There would be kidnappings\ransoms setup by al qaeda world wide. Saying to release him or people will die. He would be held up in court for years upon years and politically. His name wouldn't fade away into obscurity. It would be plastered all over the news until the day he put to a hanging. In which he would have died anyway. It would be an absolute political disaster.



^This

Originally Posted By: [LoD
Rainman]

Releasing a photo does nothing to satisfy the massive amounts of people who will never be satisfied no matter what you give them.



^ And this




Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 8,917
Adept
**
Offline
Adept
**
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 8,917
Originally Posted By: [LoD
Goldmund]

I would like to know where they got the initial sample from bin Laden for DNA comparison. Sure they are 100 percent certain the sample they took from the dead guy belonged to the dead guy... but what did they do... swab an envelope on which his name was the return addressee for the comparison?



My understanding was that they used DNA from family members for match?




Page 1 of 2 1 2

Link Copied to Clipboard
Who's Online Now
0 members (), 29 guests, and 2 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5
(Release build 20201027)
Responsive Width:

PHP: 7.4.33 Page Time: 0.017s Queries: 36 (0.006s) Memory: 11.7991 MB (Peak: 18.3044 MB) Data Comp: Off Server Time: 2025-06-14 19:36:41 UTC
Valid HTML 5 and Valid CSS